Skip to main content

Table 3 The number of various causes of action, the percentage of the total cases, the losing rate, the primary responsibility rate of doctors (50% ≤ doctor responsibility ≤ 100%), the average amount of compensation and the average amount of claim among all the litigation cases of total knee arthroplasty included in the study.

From: Litigation analysis of medical damage after total knee arthroplasty: a case study based on Chinese legal database in the past ten years

Cause of litigation

Number of cases

Percentage

The losing rate

The primary responsibility rate

The average amount of compensation

The average amount of claim

All cases

110

100%

90.9%

53.6%

¥213882.53(±285924.60)

¥472493.06 (±513106.45)

Infection

48

43.6%

95.8%

58.3%

¥209503.35(±228028.40)

¥464714.81(±385348.33)

Postoperative dysfunction

18

16.4%

88.9%

55.6%

¥79692.80(±69558.18)

¥233276.75(±202783.47)

Persistent / worsening pain

14

12.7%

78.6%

28.6%

¥68139.96(±70257.01)

¥207991.02(±176414.01)

Postoperative ischemic stroke

11

10.0%

81.8%

27.3%

¥392531.17(±697223.99)

¥778560.30(±1107434.12)

Death

9

8.2%

77.8%

33.3%

¥206881.60(±177197.91)

¥466866.64(±214933.66)

Prosthesis loosening

7

6.4%

100.0%

71.4%

¥153176.14(±150507.37)

¥357777.03(±248728.29)

Amputation

7

6.4%

100.0%

85.7%

¥629762.87(±540939.30)

¥928853.54(±553279.38)

Nerve injury

6

5.5%

100.0%

83.3%

¥196853.50(±97310.99)

¥ 525039.94(±430878.06)

Poor wound healing after operation

6

5.5%

83.3%

66.7%

¥93341.26(±121401.92)

¥264019.72(±371551.51)

Poor alignment

4

3.6%

100.0%

75.0%

¥203852.46(±198646.30)

¥577025.26(±577025.26)

Deep venous thrombosis

4

3.6%

100.0%

25.0%

¥199786.38(±180058.65)

¥713513.85(±345839.92)

Vascular injury

2

1.8%

100.0%

100.0%

¥345857.07(±247082.86)

¥696216.30(±634538.81)

  1. 18 patients (16.4%) had 2 complications and 9 patients (8.2%) had 3 or more complications. Some of the data are not recorded in the table because the quantity is too small.